Some time before the end of the year, Serie A's twenty clubs are expected to vote on whether to sell part of a company that doesn't exist yet. The league wants to put its international broadcasting rights into a new vehicle and sell a minority stake in it to a fund; JP Morgan has run the process since the summer, and by mid-October six proposals had been cut to two, with the clubs aiming for a vote "tra novembre e dicembre". According to Reuters, as reported by Calcio e Finanza, the furthest along is Avenue Capital, with a first offer of €320m for 10%, which values the whole company at €3.2bn; the other is a Nextalia–Carlyle consortium. Oaktree, which has owned Inter since a loan went unpaid, dropped out, which settles the conflict this blog's post on multi-club ownership ended on, at least for this deal.
What the €3.2bn buys
The business being priced is small next to the domestic deal. Serie A's overseas rights bring in €250–260m a year against EBITDA of about €209m, and the league's stated aim is to take that to €500–520m a season. At home, DAZN and Sky pay about €900m a season through 2028/29, and none of that goes into the new company. The same Calcio e Finanza piece sets out what JP Morgan was asked to compare: straight financing from specialist lenders, an agency to distribute the rights abroad, or a minority investor. The investor version gives the fund a "qualified minority", with a board seat and a say over commercial strategy in each region, and it needs 14 of the 20 clubs to pass. Several bidders were looking at it through their credit arms, so at least some of them see it as closer to a loan than a stake.
On Avenue's number, €3.2bn is a little over 15 times that €209m of EBITDA. The article cites 15x as the middle reference for a media asset, between a normal media company at around 10x and Formula 1's commercial rights at around 20x. A buyer paying the middle multiple on today's earnings gets about €21m a year for its €320m, a yield of roughly 6.5% before any growth; that arithmetic is mine, and it is the reason the doubling matters. The fund's return depends on the league reaching €500m, and the board seat is how it expects to help get there.
The last attempt, and three other answers
Serie A has been here before. In November 2020 the clubs approved a €1.7bn offer from CVC, Advent and FSI for 10% of a media company covering the league's rights, domestic included, which implied about €17bn for the whole. By February 2021 seven clubs no longer saw it as viable, arguing it undervalued the rights, and the deal died. The new vehicle leaves out the domestic contract, which is the bulk of the money and the part the clubs fought over. The stake in the overseas piece is worth a fifth of what the 2020 stake was, and the bet is narrower. In the meantime, three of Europe's other big leagues have each answered the same question their own way.
LaLiga took the money and fenced it. In December 2021, 37 of 42 clubs ratified a €1.994bn investment from CVC for an 8.2% stake in a new company that receives LaLiga's broadcasting and sponsorship revenues, which CVC expects to recover over 50 years. Clubs could spend up to 70% of their share on infrastructure, international growth, brand and technology, up to 15% on players and the rest on debt. Real Madrid, Barcelona, Athletic and Ibiza voted no, took none of the money, and the three big clubs have gone to court over it since.
Ligue 1 took the money and the forecast. CVC paid €1.5bn for 13% of LFP Media in 2022, a valuation of a little over €11bn, of which €750m was CVC's equity and the rest debt. The business plan assumed €1bn a year in domestic TV rights. Calcio e Finanza, citing L'Équipe, puts this season's broadcaster income at about €300m gross, and reports that CVC now values its €750m of equity at around €200m, a cut Off the Pitch put at 73%. The forecast was wrong by more than half, and CVC took a loss on paper. The €1.5bn, though, went to the league and its clubs in 2022, and the league still owes 13% of whatever LFP Media earns now.
The Bundesliga said no, barely. In December 2023 the DFL's 36 clubs voted on selling a share of up to 8% of the league's media and sponsorship revenue for about 20 years; 24 voted yes, exactly the two-thirds needed. Weeks of protests followed, with chocolate coins, bike locks and remote-controlled cars holding up matches, and on 21 February 2024 the executive committee stopped the process, saying the dispute was putting "the integrity of the competition at risk".
The instrument underneath
Without the vehicles and the board seats, all four deals are the same trade. A league sells a permanent or very long percentage of a revenue line for cash today, at a price set by someone else's forecast of that line. The buyer carries the risk that the forecast is wrong, and the French case shows that risk is real; but the percentage doesn't shrink when revenue does, so the league carries some of it too, without the cash to show for it once the money is spent. LaLiga's 70% rule was an attempt to make clubs turn the cash into something that would grow the revenue line they had sold a share of, rather than into wages.
Serie A's version is narrower on every axis. It covers only the overseas rights, the stake is 10% rather than 13%, and the buyer is being asked to help with the growth it is paying for. The narrowing also points the risk the other way from France: Avenue's price already assumes a doubling, so if the league gets to €500m on its own plan the clubs will have sold a tenth of that growth at a price fixed before they earned it, and if it doesn't they will have €320m and a fund on the board of the one business they were trying to fix.
The deal needs fourteen of the twenty clubs, so the vote will show how many of them believe the league's own plan.
No comments yet