Amortisation is a squad-building strategy

Brighton spent £210m on players in 2024/25 and their player-trading line went from a £68.1m profit to a £25m loss. For a club that buys to sell, the result is the gap between two numbers, and contract length sets one of them.

Brighton's accounts for the year to 30 June 2025 put the whole selling-club model into one line. The club spent about £210m on new players in Fabian Hürzeler's first season, and its player trading result "shifted from a profit of £68.1m to a loss of £25m"; the club reported a £54.4m loss for the year. Swiss Ramble's breakdown shows what moved underneath: profit on player sales almost halved, from £110m to £57m, while player amortisation more than doubled, from £39m to £82m. The £25m loss is roughly the gap between those two numbers. The sales that would have closed it, João Pedro to Chelsea for £60m and Simon Adingra to Sunderland for £21m, happened after the year end and sit in next year's accounts.

For a club that buys to sell, those two lines are the business, and only one of them is about the market. Profit on a sale is the fee minus the player's net book value on the day he leaves. Amortisation is the schedule that decides what that book value is, and the schedule is set by the length of the contract the club chose to sign him on.

The dial

A fee is spread in equal slices over the contract, so £50m on five years is £10m a year and the player's book value falls by £10m each season. Caicedo shows how much room the model has: Brighton paid £4.5m for him in 2021 and sold him for £115m in 2023, so almost the whole fee came through as profit, because there was almost nothing left on the books to subtract.

Length is the dial. A longer deal lowers the annual charge and keeps more of the fee on the balance sheet for longer, which shrinks the profit if the player is sold early. A shorter one puts more cost into the early seasons but writes the book value down faster, so a sale in year three books more profit. The total cost over the life of the deal is the same either way. What the club is choosing is which season carries it, and for a seller that is a bet on when the player will leave.

Since 2023 there has been a ceiling on how far the dial turns. UEFA capped amortisation at five years that summer, and on 12 December Premier League clubs voted for their own five-year maximum, which "will apply to all new or extended player contracts" but was not backdated. Chelsea's eight-year deals for Enzo Fernández, Mykhailo Mudryk and Caicedo were the reason for the vote, and the bill they spread still arrives: the club's amortisation charge reached £212m in 2024/25. The contract itself can still run longer than five years, as Erling Haaland's nine-and-a-half-year deal at City does, but the fee can't be spread past five, so the playing term and the accounting term are no longer always the same number.

Extensions are the other half of the dial, and they get reported as retention stories. When a contract is extended, the remaining book value is spread again over the new term. A player bought for £50m on five years has £30m left after two seasons; if he signs a new five-year deal at that point, the charge drops from £10m to £6m a year. The same mechanism shows up in a worked example from a 2014 sale, where a centre-back's annual charge fell to £3.84m after his new five-year deal. An extension lowers this year's cost and raises the book value the club will have to beat at sale, and it also protects the fee itself, since a player with two years left is worth less to a buyer than one with five. At a selling club, a five-year renewal for a young player is as much a transfer decision as a contract one.

When the factory runs ahead

Benfica show the model with the lines the right way round. In 2024/25 the club made €89m profit on player sales, up 52%, against an amortisation charge of €41m, on record revenue of €231m and a €37m pre-tax profit. That is sale profit at more than twice the cost of the squad's transfer fees, where Brighton's fell to about 0.7 times. Part of the difference is what Benfica sell: João Neves, who came through the academy and so had no fee on the books, went to PSG for €59.9m fixed plus up to €10m in add-ons in August 2024, and close to all of it was profit. A club whose best sales are academy players has a smaller amortisation charge to outrun.

Brighton's 2024/25 squad was built the other way, with £210m of bought players on five-year schedules starting at once. That is a choice to carry a heavy charge for several seasons in exchange for a squad with resale value, and in the first year of that cycle the charge was always going to beat the sales. Brighton have done it before: they made a then-record £122.8m profit in 2022/23 on the sales of players they had bought cheaply years earlier. The model runs in waves, and the accounts catch it at whichever point the year end happens to fall.

Both sides of the ratio

What changes from this season is where those two numbers sit in the rules. The Premier League's Squad Cost Ratio, whose revenue definition this series has already covered, limits squad costs to 85% of football revenue, and its definitions put "amortisation or impairment of transfer fees" in the costs and net profit or loss from player sales in the revenue. UEFA's 70% version for clubs in Europe does the same, adding the result on player disposals to the revenue it counts.

So for a selling club the amortisation schedule now sits on both sides of the ratio: the charge is in the numerator every year, and the book value it leaves behind decides how much sale profit reaches the denominator. Brighton's 2024/25 shape, amortisation up and sale profit down, moves the ratio the wrong way on both sides at once, and a year when the big sales land pulls it back.

That makes the timing of sales a compliance question as well as a market one. João Pedro's £60m move was announced on 2 July 2025, two days after the year it would have rescued closed, and the next round of Brighton's sales will be measured against five-year schedules that started together in 2024. Can a club that buys a squad in one window sell it in time to stay ahead of its own amortisation?

No comments yet